| Tahun | Pemenang dan nominee | Perancang |
| 1996 | Evita | Penny Rose |
| Hamlet | Alex Byrne |
| Moll Flanders | Consolata Boyle |
| The Portrait of a Lady | Janet Patterson |
| Ridicule | Christian Gasc |
| 1997 | Titanic | Deborah L. Scott |
| Amistad | Ruth E. Carter |
| Beaumarchais the Scoundrel (Beaumarchais, l'insolent) | Sylvie De Segonzac |
| Mrs. Brown | Deidre Clancy |
| The Wings of the Dove | Sandy Powell |
| 1998 | Elizabeth | Alexandra Byrne |
| Beloved | Colleen Atwood |
| Ever After | Jenny Beavan |
| Pleasantville | Judianna Makovsky |
| Shakespeare in Love | Sandy Powell |
| 1999 | Sleepy Hollow | Colleen Atwood |
| Anna and the King | Jenny Beavan |
| The Emperor and the Assassin (Jing ke ci qin wang) | Mo Xiaomin |
| An Ideal Husband | Caroline Harris |
| The Red Violin (Le violon rouge) | Renee April |
| Titus | Milena Canonero |
